Honest description
Honest description, fast and good service, beautiful diamonds and excellent prices!
Anne F.
Was this helpful?
Calavera New York
5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 27, 2026Do you agree with Calavera New York's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 59 customers have already said.
calaveranewyork.comMember since Mar 2026
Calavera New York is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 27, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Very happy with my purchase
Very happy with my purchase, the quality and pricing were competitive. Also the terrific customer service and sample videos provided. Thank you 🙏🏼
Elias Nyktas
Was this helpful?
This is a legit place can’t wait to…
This is a legit place can’t wait to come back and buy a bigger diamond!
Bella Camarillo
Was this helpful?
Package was never received
I’m a satisfied customer
Sean Blunt
Was this helpful?
Great selection and good price
Great selection and good price
Jane
Was this helpful?
I would definitely order again
I would definitely order again. We got the diamond already on the ring it came out beautiful!! Can’t wait to buy again!!
Tyler Rader
Was this helpful?
Diamonds are beautiful
Diamonds are beautiful. Just as described. Fast service and safe delivery. Will order again.
RG....a very much great full customer!
Was this helpful?
Great Diamonds
I purchased a 2.66 CT Oval VVS2 D color diamond, it was IGI certified as well. It is absolutely stunning and it was a great price. Processing took about 2 weeks and when I emailed for an update they were quick to reply. I am absolutely in love with my purchase.
Toniann Wallace
Was this helpful?
Great finds on their website
Great finds on their website. If your looking for reasonable priced lab diamonds.
Luann Bordon
Was this helpful?
Excellent experience
Excellent experience. I purchased a stunning 1.5-carat round brilliant loose diamond, and when I searched the IGI certificate number, I found the same diamond retailing for four times as much on other sites. It took 6 days to get tracking information but once that came through they kept me updated on my package via email and shipping was speedy, arriving in two days. 10/10 would recommend
Jessica Poolman
Was this helpful?
Pretty quick process and great quality…
Pretty quick process and great quality packaging
John
Was this helpful?
10 out of 10
10 out of 10. The diamond is beautiful and well received by my girlfriend. Shipping was a little bit of a hassle, but it had nothing to do with you, only the weather and my stress level. Lol. Customer service was outstanding! Thank you all very much and I will be a repeat customer..
Mark Mazur
Was this helpful?
Calavera offers the best price and service
Not only does Calavera offer the best prices on diamonds, but the company also delivers exceptional service. Jaden, the Director of Calavera Concierge, is attentive, knowledgeable, and truly focused on providing exactly what you’re looking for—far beyond what a local jeweler typically offers. I’ll definitely be returning for future orders. Thank you Jaden for the best experience buying diamond online
trang
Was this helpful?
Package came within the time frame…
Package came within the time frame given. Diamond was as advertised and looks amazing. Great price as advertised. Overall perfect experience.
Joseph Gan
Was this helpful?
Great value
Writing this review because I was super cautious before buying because there wasn’t a lot of info on this site but the prices were great. I started small and bought (2) .38kt natural diamonds and they were exactly what I ordered and came with certification and serial number matched. I will be buying again. I made stud earrings and they are gorgeous even the jewelry said I did good.
Brandy
Was this helpful?
Great shipping details
Delivery was on point and item was beautiful
Anonymous
Was this helpful?
Prices were great and I received my…
Prices were great and I received my stones in about 10 days.
Amanda Williams
Was this helpful?
Great Experience!
Everything about my Cavalera experience was an A+. The purchase was very simple. The diamond came in a timely manner as expected. The customer service representatives were very responsive and patient. Shout out to Jayden who I dealt with and was very patient every step of the way. The diamond was top quality, and gorgeous! I am very happy I purchased from them and I highly recommend them!!
Leela Viswanathan
Was this helpful?
Great service and pricing
Great service and pricing
nate nehls
Was this helpful?
Really good quality
Really good quality! Can’t wait to order more!
TT
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Calavera New York has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/calaveranewyork-com