Trust PlaneTrustPlane
Story In Steel logo

Story In Steel

4.250 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 26, 2026

Do you agree with Story In Steel's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 125 customers have already said.

storyinsteel.comMember since Mar 2026

Story In Steel is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 26, 2026.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
50 reviews

Save your money - not as promised

I’m extremely disappointed with my experience ordering from Story in Steel.After multiple rounds of correspondence, I carefully reviewed and approved a final proof that did not include their company logo. However, the product I received arrived with their logo added, which was not part of the approved design.In addition to the incorrect proof execution, the overall product quality was far below expectations. The craftsmanship and finish did not reflect the level of quality represented during the ordering process.I reached out several times to customer service to address both the unauthorized logo addition and the quality concerns. Unfortunately, I did not receive a response, nor was I offered a refund or replacement.Based on my experience, I cannot recommend ordering from this company. I would strongly encourage others to proceed with caution and ensure all details are clearly documented before purchasing.

AmyS
Was this helpful?

Excellent product

While I opted not to pay for expedited service, the product showed up within the 15 day time frame. Both the approval picture they sent, and the actual delivered product turned out amazing. I will be looking for products from them.

Gary Paris
Was this helpful?

I saw the Story In Steel ad on Facebook

I wanted to surprise my wife for Christmas. My wife Loves her Fur Baby's. I sent 9 photos of her Fur Baby's to Story In Steel. They organized them perfectly and put all their names at the bottom of the Art Work. It turned out better than I had expected, and my wife was very happy!!! I worked with Nolan at Story In Steel, he is a Man of his word. THANK YOU Team Story In Steel!!!John & Laura

John
Was this helpful?

Beautiful portrait of our dogs

Story in Steel transformed our favorite picture of our two dogs into a lovely steel portrait that we can now enjoy in our living room every day. Excellent quality. Shipped in a protective box. Overall, we are very pleased with the product. The one thing to think about it that it takes them a couple of weeks to produce, so you have to plan ahead (my gift was late, but all was forgiven when my wife saw the portrait ;-)

Scott
Was this helpful?

Professional, precise, great business!!

You guys did great!!! Great communication to make sure it was what I wanted, you guys changed things a couple of times on the picture to make sure I was satisfied and that it was 100 percent to my liking, did great with the picture, not a flaw on it, shipping was as said and on time, great job!!! Surely this is professional business being done with a great staff!!! Thank you all very much for the great work, time and precision!!!!

Dank
Was this helpful?

Anniversary

I gave my wife this for our anniversary. It was a picture of us getting married on a beach in Tahiti and it turned out absolutely amazing. My wife absolutely loved it. I think it was probably one of the best gifts I have given her. So worth the money.

Tory Piecyk
Was this helpful?

Thanks for this beautiful renemberance

This story in steel is a picture of my deceased wife when she was young closing a clasp on her dress. I appreciate the artist signature but I suggest it would also be nice to give the option of having the photographer's signature at the bottom left. This is my second Story in Steel. They are well made, and quite sturdy. I like the new magnetic mount between the backing board and the steel image. The magnets are extremely strong. I also appreciate the wall brackets that are pre-installed. Again, thanks for the rendering.

Ronald
Was this helpful?

The custom pet portrait was beyond my…

The custom pet portrait was beyond my expectations!! Beautiful and a memory that we will have forever, thank you!!

Rachel
Was this helpful?

Do not recommend

Unfortunately, this company does not appear to value customer service. This was evident in the lack of follow-through and the quality of work that was initially guaranteed. Feedback was clearly provided; however, I was advised to spend additional money—albeit at a discounted rate—to correct the product. You will not receive the product in a timely manner either. The response and resolution ultimately fell short of expectations.

tim schaff
Was this helpful?

Very happy story in steel customer

I got a story in steel for my father-in-law for Christmas. It was a picture of him and my late mother-in-law dancing at my son‘s wedding. We had some missing pieces but they were quickly mailed to us and he absolutely loves it. I had a great experience with the order, the missing parts, and the finished product is excellent!

Nanette Barcellos
Was this helpful?

Great customer service from Story in Steel

One of the spacers on my Story in Steel picture had a flaw in it. This picture was a gift for Christmas. I sent a message to the email address provided. The response was very fast. I was asked to provide pictures of the flawed part. Once provided a whole new kit was sent immediately. Nolan was the representative I was dealing with and he was just awesome.

Mandy Smith
Was this helpful?

We were promised delivery by Christmas…

We were promised delivery by Christmas and still have not received the item.

maggie apprill
Was this helpful?

In memory of our beloved dogs

We recently lost our two dogs. Our niece had the most amazing piece created for us. Both dogs were portrayed perfectly. Great workmanship and amazing quality!We will definitely keep Story In Steel in mind for future pieces.

J Bagley
Was this helpful?

Great experience and craftsmanship from…

Great experience and craftsmanship from beginning to end! So glad I found Story in Steel for the perfect gift to my wife on our 11th anniversary, which is traditionally a gift made from steel.

RAYMOND IAVASILE
Was this helpful?

Unmet Expectations

Approved my proofs and it took over a month to recieve my order (even after paying extra for expedited shipping). Missed my deadline to give as a funeral gift. The metal finish is grossly misleading. Actual finish i received is light gray as oppose to metallic silver that is shown on all the pictures. Overall, I will not be using them again as the overall experience did not meet expectations.

Washington Parzels
Was this helpful?

I received the picture today and it…

I received the picture today and it exceeded my expectations. It was beautiful and extremely well made. If you are looking for a unique gift that will impress, order from this company. Customer service is great and they ship in a timely fashion. Have only positive things to say about my experience and will definitely order again! Thanks so much!!

Karen Biddinger
Was this helpful?

Terrible customer service and failure to respond

Terrible customer service. Despite reaching out for updates and confirmation of our promised delivery date we have not even received a response. Incredibly unprofessional experience.

Unhappy customer
Was this helpful?

Looks like a scam

I ordered a week before Thanksgiving (11/19), approved the design 11/20, and it is now 12/19 and I have not heard anything about my order nor have I received it. I have reached out 4 times; 1x via the the website, 2x via email, and 1x via FB messenger. The website still advertises you can order in time for Christmas. This is looking like a scam.

GT
Was this helpful?

Misleading advertising

What a cool idea to take a photo and turn it into something unique. But here I am watching Story in steel post advertisements how you can still order in time for Christmas and I have yet to receive my order that was created just after Thanksgiving. Yes, the design itself wasn’t approved until December 2 because of a glitch on their part, but I paid for expedited service to name up for it, (it is a 5 to 15 day turnaround and I was well within their window, but still no product). There’s no way in heck this is gonna arrive in time for Christmas let alone all of those poor suckers who think that if they ordered just last week it would get there in time. Give yourself two months— that’s my advice or _order_from_somebody_else_.

Linda Simonin
Was this helpful?

Giant logo, no response

Ordered artwork in September, received in October. I had signed off on the design concept because I was unaware that the logo for the company features prominently on the front of the artwork and it is not able to be covered. I posted a negative review stating I was not happy with the product and received a personal communication through text from "Jumz" stating they would make it right. They have since stopped responding completely. It is now December.

Morgan
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, Story In Steel has a 4.2/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/storyinsteel-com