Do you agree with MakeYourPuzzles's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 81 customers have already said.
MakeYourPuzzles is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 26, 2026.
Ensured my order would be processed and arrived to me within specific timeframe. However -1 star for miscommunication and not answering my questions in follow up emails. Due to this, it had given me anxiety and uncertainty regarding my order for about 5 days.
Fast, easy and super cute! Bought for a wedding shower. Guests will write on the back of the pieces! Love it!😍 woudl purchase again.
My custom puzzle turned out great. Perfect size (500 pieces) and the pieces came in a good variety of shapes, not just one or two types of shapes. Colors look great on the thick "paper/cardboard" pieces and a very sturdy puzzle. Will glue it and frame it next.
Speedy delivery and great quality. We really enjoyed the puzzle. The fact that it was eco‑friendly, made in the U.S., and from a family‑owned business was a real feather in the cap!
Quality puzzles, ships quickly. I’ve ordered three and made this one of my “go tos”when looking for a unique gift for someone.
I needed a custom puzzle done in a very short timeframe before the recipient leaves for 8 months, and MakeYourPuzzle was the only company that could make and deliver a custom puzzle within a week. It was also the cheapest option I found, even with the fast turnover. The puzzle ended up arriving two days earlier than planned, which was incredible. I honestly expected a lot lower quality for the price and speed, and was pleasantly surprised by the quality overall. The box was very nice and professional. The recipient didn't even know it was a custom puzzle, it was so fancy. A lot of times with puzzles, you get some pretty jagged edges. The pieces on this puzzle were immaculate. I am EXTREMELY pleased with my purchase and will 100% be using MakeYourPuzzles for my custom puzzle needs in the future.
We love our puzzle from last year, so we had some more puzzles created this year for gifts.
It is fast and extremely reliable with sharp cuts in the puzzle for a sharper photo.
I ordered this puzzle for a family member for Christmas and I can't wait to give it to him it is so unique and I'm sure it will be something that he will keep I'm so glad I discovered this website this gift is so beautiful
I'm not well versed in editing photos and wanted a specific layered look of a single photo. Customer service advised me and I was able to figure it out and submit the look I wanted for the puzzle. It was shipping within a couple of days. Wonderful customer service. Thank-you!
This is a gift for my 7 year old granddaughter who loves puzzles. I am certain she will enjoy assembling her personalized puzzle!! The box is beautiful so I am certain the puzzle pieces will be equally bright and made with care.
This was a reorder for special anniversary puzzles for our public library celebration. Patrons placed orders with us and Make Your Puzzles got the puzzles printed and shipped very quickly. Customer service was quick, responsive and very personable! This company worked with us on the first order round a few months ago. They were were great to work with and answered all of our questions, all while giving us the best price and using good old fashioned customer service.
I deleted my last review I thought it was for puzzle you . Make your puzzles is far superior print quality is always great shipping is pretty fast I have purchased several puzzles from this site and will use them whenever I have a custom puzzle made.very happy customer.
The puzzle was fun and easy to create and the result is great quality and will be perfect to serve as the guest book at my daughter's wedding because the size of the puzzle pieces are not too small and not too large, just right for a name and a short wedding wish!
While the jigsaw puzzle pieces appeared to fit, when they did not, this is still the BEST quality jigsaw puzzle for custom photo puzzles that I have found. If you have a fairly clear, easy picture for your puzzle, should be happily enjoyed. I recommend MakeYourPuzzles for custom photo jigsaw puzzles.
Your web site is very user friendly, the puzzles are delivered so quickly, and they turn out beautiful every time!
Quick shipping, great quality, and beautiful picture. I think these would make excellent gifts for the “person who has everything”!
Fast shipping, great product, beautiful puzzle pieces. Gives a person something to create that's unique and precisely arranged as you put it together.
I had questions regarding image quality before placing an order. They replied very quickly during our emails back and forth. The shipping was good and arrived in great shape. The box looks amazing. The puzzle will not be put together until after the birthday girl opens it. Hopefully all goes well, and all 1000 pieces are there.
Ordering a puzzle with a family photo printed on it was amazingly easy! Als, you was astounded by how quickly the beautiful puzzle was delivered. It was a great experience!
According to TrustPlane, MakeYourPuzzles has a 4.9/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/makeyourpuzzles-com
