Do you agree with Choice Mutual's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 1,521 customers have already said.
Choice Mutual is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 19, 2026.
Five stars for Choice Mutual! I was looking for burial insurance and was amazed at how fast the process was—I was approved in less than 30 minutes. Their website is easy to use, and the agent I spoke with was a true professional who knew exactly which company would offer me the best rate for my health.
Choice Mutual provides clear and helpful guidance for finding the right insurance. The team was responsive and explained options without any pressure. It's a trustworthy service for anyone navigating Medicare or other coverage decisions.
Anthony was kind, professional, and very easy to work with. He answered my questions promptly and provided excellent guidance, helping me make an important insurance decision with confidence.
Take care to thoroughly explore all options that best suit the individual before presenting them as available choices.
My experience with Brian Barber was excellent. He helped me find a great option for final expense insurance and went above and beyond to make sure everything went through smoothly. Even after the fact I had missed a payment and he followed up to make sure I knew. Which I didn't and I'm grateful that he did. If I needed any other insurance Brian Barber is the only person I'd go through. He's very knowledgeable, easy to talk to and easy to get a hold of!
Anthony is an awesome insurance agent who assisted me professionally. Great experience with him helping
It has an attractive logo and it has perfect quality n it's slow
The Positive: What made this process great was the one on one attention I received with Anthony Martin. The fact I received call backs when I was told I would receive them. The Negative: I was expecting to answer health questions and I did with Anthony Martin. However I was unaware that I would receive another call to go over my personal information and health questions again by another representative. Why was that necessary???
Anthony made the application and follow up a great experience. Much difference than an earlier experience with another company where the individual was really a combative and hardsell representative.
The man Anthony Martin helped me and was very helpful and very easy to talk to, for such a important thing in life.i like him and will always remember.
Anthony Martin was very professional, kind, caring and very pleasant to talk to. He w as prompt in returning my phone calls. he made the process very easy and simple.He was very patient with me on the phone to walk me through on how to work the computer. He deserves a raise. Thank You!
Anthony was Awesomely Awesome!
Anthony was great. He was kind and explained everything in detail. He also got everything done very quickly. I couldn't have ask for a better agent.
Anthony was very knowledgeable and supportive. He is an asset to your brokerage
The Rep i talked to was very nice and caring and very helpful and the price i pit was very reasonable for my age thanks for your help.
Good price. Easy to work with. No hard sell. No bait and switch.So far so good.
BETTER PRICE AND DIDN'T TAKE A LONG TIME.
Anthony was very helpful explaining the application process. He was in constant contact and was very professional.
I had tried 2 different agents,1 kept me on the phone for over 2 hrs.Brian Barber was my 3rd call.I could not have ask for a nicer agent.He explained, gave me choices and got approved right then.ThanksBryan.
Excellent service overall I was happy with the service with Anthony Martin
According to TrustPlane, Choice Mutual has a 4.8/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/choicemutual-com
