Prompt service and response
Prompt service and response. Definitely recommend.
Tdg
Was this helpful?
Sell My Games
5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 28, 2026Do you agree with Sell My Games's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 539 customers have already said.
sellmygames.comMember since Feb 2026
Sell My Games is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 28, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Communication was excellent
Communication was excellent. Really appreciated status updates.
Dan Kiel
Was this helpful?
I had an amazing experience
I had an amazing experience. They were fast and there payout was more then expected!! I would deff do business again
kayla foy
Was this helpful?
Great transaction
Everything about this transaction was wonderful. Prepaid shipping and quick processing.
Jason Day
Was this helpful?
Highly recommend!
This service was so easy to use and when I had questions, the staff responded right away and were friendly and professional. The whole process was so easy to use and I love that it was free to ship this stuff!
Jennifer Heleniak
Was this helpful?
Quick payment
Quick payment
Derek Murphy
Was this helpful?
Easy and Fast
Super easy to log and send off my games. Very happy with the experience.
Adam Carlson
Was this helpful?
True to their word!!
True to their word!!! Best in the business! Would never even think of going with anyone else!!!!
BRUCE WOOTEN
Was this helpful?
Extremely nice service
Extremely nice service. They'll send you a detailed description of what they're paying you for and why. Also, what was really surprising is you could do a back and forth with the person handling your items. When I asked why a certain item was worth what it was, the extremely courteous person on the other line negotiated with me. I never thought a service like this would do so; extremely grateful for that. A really pleasant surprise.
Benjamin Jacob Schwartz
Was this helpful?
positive transaction
good company little bit cheaper on the games but systems price was nice overall positive transaction
Owen
Was this helpful?
Extremely Simple Process
Extremely Simple Process. Fair price paid.
Matt Sundberg
Was this helpful?
The process was so easy
The process was so easy! They reviewed my items within 48 hours of receiving them and paid me through Venmo. They offered significantly more than what my local store (a chain) offered. Highly recommend!
JP
Was this helpful?
Great
Great! So easy and simple to use. I love that I can just slap on the label and postage is paid. I received payment very quickly after sending my games.
Caroline
Was this helpful?
Promises kept!
They make it very simple and transparent. Everything worked as promised, and according to package tracking, I don't think they had my discs at their offices for more than 2 hours before they Venmo'd me the amount they offered!
Marc Natanagara
Was this helpful?
Great experience
Great experience. Super easy process. Questions answered quickly.
Erin A
Was this helpful?
Great Experience
Sell My Games was easy to use and had a quick turn around time. I appreciate the updates via email and the clear summary I received on any adjustments made. I have already recommended Sell My Games to others and I would use it again.
Victoria V
Was this helpful?
Selling my video games was quick and convenient
Selling my video games to Sellmygames.com was shockingly convenient. I sent the games using the prepaid USPS label they provided, and within a few days they'd received my package, inspected the items, and remunerated the agreed amount via Venmo. Seriously, I wish I'd have known about this company years ago!
John .
Was this helpful?
Super fast payment and very quick to…
Super fast payment and very quick to respond with any issues. Andrew was super informative attentive and helpful. Will do business again very soon and recommend them. A+++++++
Otha Norris
Was this helpful?
They did everything they promised…
They did everything they promised quickly and efficiently.
Mary Wyman
Was this helpful?
Pays good money for your games
Pays good money for your games
Dan Borud
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Sell My Games has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/sellmygames-com