Do you agree with McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 65 customers have already said.
McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed November 13, 2024.
I've been dealing with Annemarie and Nicole for over 4 years and have nothing but great things to say about them. They are very caring and concerned about your needs and on point with service request, they make renting a pleasure.
We have owned our place in Florida since 2005. When we moved to New Zealand in 2007, it made short term holiday rentals (and personal trips) impractical, and Anne Marie and Nicole stepped in to make a long term rental arrangement a sensible and workable next step. We always had confidence that they would take care of our interests from the other side of the world, and we have benefitted from their experience all the way through. They have done just that, and when we took the decision to sell, they gave sound advice and handled the sale efficiently. We were sold within 2 months, bringing an end to our 19 year ownership journey in Florida. A big thank you to you both. It's been a pleasure.
Fantastic response time with repair issues. While we don't have many and some seem very small the service we receive when we do have one has been amazing. The staff at Renters Choice Home keeps you notified on the status of the repairs and the teams that come out for the repairs have been polite, on time and very helpful. We have rented this home for nearly eight years and have nothing but praise for the team!
Anne-Marie, Nicole, and everyone I have come in contact at the office have always provided expedient, quality service. They hold us as tenants to a high standard which speaks volumes to who they are and their service to the owners. Their management, structure, and character is exemplified in the communication and service we have with them. Looking forward to many more years with this company and assistance when the time comes to find our very own Home.
Anne-Marie and Nicole are the very Top End of realtors for rentals and sales, they managed our property for several years, nothing was too much trouble with lots fo good advise always. When it came to selling our Condo, we closed after 2 weeks on the market,Amazing We highly recommend Renters Choice Homes SIMPLY THE BEST
Anne-Marie and Nicole have been taking care of our rental home for eight years.They have always answered all of our questions and addressed the tenants needs. When we decided to sell Anne-Marie advised us on how to get it ready. It sold in four days. Way to go Renters Choice Homes, Thank You Craig and Pam Dimmig
Anne Marie and staff have been superb managing our unit for the last several years no phone or e mail left unanswered always available sourcing all repairs at the right price and now we are selling the unit and they found a buyer in two days We’ll done guys
Excellent customer service!!
I've been living in a rental from this company for 5 years now and it's been the best living situation I've ever been in. They are quick to respond, easy to get problems fixed, and very understanding. I can't suggest a property from this company enough!
Great company! Looked after leasing my house in florida for many years. Recently listed my property sold with 3 days and monies were sent to my bank within 6 weeks. Amazingly smooth transaction.Anne Marie has been a pleasure to deal with every step of the way. Thankyou.
Anne Marie and the team have been managing my property for 10+ yrsI was in a bit of pickle doing short term holiday rentals which was a struggle post GFC for a few years and the team came in and sorted everything i needed to switch to long term rentals which was absolutely the right move. Everything just ran so much smoother from there. Of course property is not without hiccups from time to time but the team have always been available to communicate and deal with what ever life has thrown at us along the way. Thanks so much to McCormack Realty and Renters Choice homes! It was nice knowing i had a safe and willing pair of hands taking care of everything locally for me, its very much appreciated.Just recently i sold and they even took care of this also. Everything went extremely smooth - thanks so much for your guidance and advice. Great result.
Being using the company for a number of years now both for letting my property and managing the subsquent sale. Fantastic service on both accounts and always mindful of the needs of the owner as well as the renter. Would throughly recommend.
Thank you very much Anne-Marie for providing the product warranty details and the photos of the new Air Conditioning system, a credible installer indeed who looks after their clients. More importantly thank you, Nicole and Nick for the prompt resolution of the property issue, as you have done always. It’s over 12 years to this January when I saw you at my house and you have looked after the house ever since. Such a piece of mind when I am so far far away. Thank you.
I cannot rate McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes highly enough. Anne-Marie, Nicole, Nick and the team provide excellent customer service, they are friendly, efficient, always ready to answer your questions, advise and assist you. They have managed our property for the last 7 years and I can honestly say you will not find a better company to look after your property. Highly recommended.
I have only good things to say about McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes - they have provided me with a fantastic personal service ever since I engaged them several years ago to look after my rental home in Kissimmee. As a foreign resident it was important to me that I could totally rely on them to deal with all aspects of the tenancy and property maintenance on my behalf.I have recently sold my property, and again they couldn't have been more helpful in dealing with the property agents and the legal team, patiently explaining to me the intricacies of the US house sale system and making useful recommendations to ensure I got the best value out of the sale.If I could give them 6 stars, I would. Thank you, Anne-Marie, Nicole and Nick!
We have been renting off Renter's Choice for over 4 years now and we have never had any issues. All requests are dealt with promptly and the team are so nice and easy to work with.
Due to health problems I have reluctantly been forced to sell my much loved property in th popular Davenport area of Florida which I purchased in 1999. The sale was dealt with, seemingly without a hitch, by Anne-Marie, Nicole and Nick of McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes, and my thanks also go to them for managing the property so efficiently for the previous 4 years or so. Being the fourth managing agent that I had dealt with over the years, I was pleasantly surprised and impressed by the transparency of their dealings with my property, highlighted by their online financial system which provided me with complete peace of mind. Being at such a distance, this was something I had not experienced before. I cannot speak too highly of this Company and the staff’s extreme care in providing a friendly, efficient and prompt service, always being helpful especially following hurricane damage, by organising the assessment and repair of the property. Highly recommended! You will not be disappointed.
I've been with McCormack reality renters choice homes for quite a few years now anytime I need to talk to them or have a problem there always there at the end of the phone to help whether something small or bigger you can rely on them to do what needs to be done there the best realtor you could ask for you couldn't have anyone as nice there like family the best I'm really glad they have my back
I have been dealing with McCormack Realty for a few years now and have had nothing but great experience with them. They are very quick to responding and keep on top of any issues or repairs you might need which is very reassuring you are in good hands especially when you can’t be there to take care of it yourself. I would highly recommend McCormack Renters for your home if you want peace of mind and professionalism they are very hands on when something needs to be taken care of immediately, so glad I chose to deal with them.Thanks Donna Cameron
I've been with Renters Choice Homes for 8 years now and would highly recommend them to any prospective tenant, owner or seller. I have always found them to be very helpful; Anne-Marie and Nicole take care of everything and have reliable tradesmen to swiftly carry out repairs, no matter how big or small.Overall I think they provide an outstanding service no matter what they are dealing with on your behalf. Many thanks to Anne-Marie, Nick, Nicole and the rest of the team for always being on the ball. Well done!
According to TrustPlane, McCormack Realty & Renters Choice Homes has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/renterschoicehomes-com
