Trust PlaneTrustPlane
Polyvinyl Record Co. logo

Polyvinyl Record Co.

3.68 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 9, 2026

Do you agree with Polyvinyl Record Co.'s TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 8 customers have already said.

polyvinylrecords.comMember since Mar 2026

Polyvinyl Record Co. is an online company. Based on 8 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 3.6 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 9, 2026.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
8 reviews

So first the package came late I…

So first the package came late I ordered 2 day priority I ordered it the second of February and it came the 9th it missed my friends birthday but not only that the package came open and it was inside a bag one it was here, then I could’ve excused all that but the hum cd downward is heavenward came cracked luckily it works but I spent 60 dollars on this and I was not expecting it at all does not help that Valentine’s Day is coming up and I planned on buying more but seeing how this order went I don’t plan to again.

Eduardo Canseco
Was this helpful?

Paying taxe

Well good production, came from far away so a bit long to receive. But what I didn't like is that they didn't tell me when I entered the shipping adress that i would have to pay a taxe because of the travel. I paid 16€ when it arrived and had to pay it or else they would have to take it back. Yes maybe they don't know how much it will be depending on the area or country, but just letting people know that they could pay a tax in case they're far away would have been appreciated.

Clara Tonnelé-Verjus
Was this helpful?

Slow shipping but airheads 😍😍

Shipping was slow since it was thanksgiving, but you get an airhead and points towards free stuff which is neat. The records came in a box and were slightly injured in the corner but that’s what you get for ordering online ig. Would recommend for the airhead alone!.

Benjamin
Was this helpful?

Really Bad LP's, Regret Purchasing

I am very frustrated with the quality of the records I've gotten from this company. I got Alvvvays and Strfkr brand-new from them, both dreamy kinds of music, and both albums are plagued by static and pops no matter how thoroughly I've washed them. These defects completely tear down the songs and break there immersion. The next time i want a record and Polyvinyl is producing it, I am definitely going for the CD version.

Kyle Seeley
Was this helpful?

I've order two records from them

I've order two records from them, American Football LP 1 and 2 and each time I got an airhead with them, I love airheads my preferred flavors each time too. 11/10

Devin Pavlik
Was this helpful?

Ordered from them a few times with no…

Ordered from them a few times with no problems! They always throw in some stickers and even candy, and a note that tells you the name of the person who packaged your record. I like that.

Cassidy Kiddo
Was this helpful?

Definitely recommended

Ordered an of Montreal shirt, really good pricing for shipping from USA to UK and was pretty fast, included a few cool freebies too, great quality shirt, great selection of artists too, would recommend and I'm going to use again

Samuel
Was this helpful?

Really good site

I ordered some records from the US to Denmark, and already got them within a week! They had a nice selektion of music by Of Montreal that I wasn't able to find anywhere else. Really good site, I will definitely shop there again.

Alice Bernth Fleischer
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, Polyvinyl Record Co. has a 3.6/5 rating based on 8 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/polyvinylrecords-com