Outstanding experience
Outstanding experience! Renee and Kristy were patient, collaborative, and a pleasure to work with on the design. Highly recommend Plum.
Karol Hammes
Was this helpful?
Plum Diamonds
5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 26, 2026Do you agree with Plum Diamonds's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 293 customers have already said.
plumdiamonds.comMember since Feb 2026
Plum Diamonds is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 26, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
I really love getting an idea of my…
I really love getting an idea of my style and possible likes and dislikes from the comfort of my home. I didn't feel pressured by a jeweler to sell. I was rushed or overwhelmed. It was a great experience.
Haley
Was this helpful?
great customer service
great customer service. beautiful piece for the price. excellent value
Mason Jeakle
Was this helpful?
Delivered a beautiful ring!
Delivered a beautiful ring!
Dalton Mertz
Was this helpful?
Beautiful tennis bracelet
Beautiful tennis bracelet. Sparkles so much it hurts your eyes. Very fast turnaround!
Doug from colorado
Was this helpful?
Looks great
Recieved the ring in a timely manner and its exactly what we wanted
Chance T Casey
Was this helpful?
The ring is beautiful!!!!
The ring is beautiful! Your team went above and beyond to making sure I received this on time. Best customer service I’ve ever recieved.
Jordan Thomas
Was this helpful?
The customer service is incredible!!
The customer service is incredible!!! The Rings are made quickly, not all are very affordable butnthere are many options that are lower in price. Im in love with my ring and i know my future fiance will lovebit too!
Dalin Scott
Was this helpful?
Best place to buy a ring!
Everyone with the company was so quick to respond, answered all my questions quickly and thoroughly. The design is beautiful, the shipping was quick and the box is beautiful.
Jasmin Samz
Was this helpful?
I had a fantastic experience with Plum…
I had a fantastic experience with Plum Diamonds. Renée was knowledgeable, patient, and very helpful throughout the entire process. She answered all my questions, provided clear information and videos, and made everything easy and stress-free. The ring is absolutely beautiful and exactly what I hoped for. I would definitely recommend Plum Diamonds.
Lisa Melendez Trily
Was this helpful?
Costumer service was phenomenal
Costumer service was phenomenal, and was willing to work with me. My email does not load while at work and they were willing to transition to text to help accommodate me. It seems like a small thing but I had a very tight deadline and being able to receive text updates I can see was great.
Jacob Jones
Was this helpful?
The most gorgeous ring I’ve ever seen…
The most gorgeous ring I’ve ever seen in my life! I wouldn’t trade this experience for the world. I will sing praises from the rooftop forever!
Ashley Grenz
Was this helpful?
Excellent customer service
Excellent customer service, quick communication, and the ring looked great!
Josh Blake
Was this helpful?
I have yet to purchase a ring from Plum…
I have yet to purchase a ring from Plum Diamonds, but I look forward to once I narrow it down to what I want. I am upgrading and can’t decide on just one! I have purchased 2 custom ring kits and have been super impressed with the communication.
Liz
Was this helpful?
10/10 would buy again
Let me start off with that I would 10/10 buy from Plum again. I absolutely love the ring, and my now fiancé, loves the ring as well! We did the pre kit before and it was the best thing to do. That way when it came time to ask, I wasn’t trying to put on a ring that didn’t fit nor did she have to wait for a resize to show off the bling. ONLY reason for a loss of star was the price of the band compared to the price of the lab diamond. We got a 1.5c in a top clarity and the band was the same price. It wasn’t anything fancy either. Take that as you’d like, I don’t know much about the cost of metals though lol.
Joshua Montelongo
Was this helpful?
Excellent customer service
Excellent customer service. Very responsive and received my order on time with a personal card and well packaged.
Tabitha Cardey
Was this helpful?
At-Home Try on Kit
I ordered the at-home try on kit and was so impressed with the handwritten card, ring options, and overall packaging. This was my first experience trying on rings and it absolutely helped me not feel overwhelmed with the season of life I am in/entering into!
Sierra Martine
Was this helpful?
It felt very personable
It felt very personable, even though I was ordering something online. It felt like they really took the time and listened to what I wanted and curated a box especially for me.
Shelby Morris
Was this helpful?
Plum Diamonds is wonderful
Plum diamonds delivered on its promise of creating a beautiful diamond tennis bracelet and matching necklace. The pieces are stunning. I highly recommend this store.
Mike
Was this helpful?
Above expectations!
Everything from the beginning was excellent. Communication was clear and responses were very prompt.
Fria
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Plum Diamonds has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/plumdiamonds-com