No worries
The company assured us the logo and printing on the History Museum pencils was the exact same as last year and they were!!! We were very happy because we did not have any worries.
Larry and Geraline Castle
Was this helpful?
Pencilguyshop
4.950 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 17, 2026Do you agree with Pencilguyshop's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 714 customers have already said.
pencilguyshop.comMember since Feb 2026
Pencilguyshop is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 17, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
The pencils look great
The pencils look great. I will use them again.
wheeler
Was this helpful?
I got exactly what I wanted
I got exactly what I wanted. It was a quick turn around from ordering to receiving the pencils. Our Honors English team was thrilled with the product!
Jennifer Blackwell
Was this helpful?
Prevent classroom pencil theft - label your pencils with your subject and room number!
Bought these (outof pocket) for my classroom, kids always taking the pencils (and honestly the Ticonderoga pencils are so cheaply made). I love these. It's been 3 days and none are missing! The blue was brighter in the ad, but they are still nice. They keep rolling off the tables, but thats due to uneven tables and perfectly round pencils. The pencils sharpen nicely and keep a nice point. When I run out of these I will reorder. They arrived super fast.
Art Teacher
Was this helpful?
Great Customer Service
Brian contacted me quickly with a proof of what I ordered and I had my order in hand within a week. The pencils came out great!
Laura Cassellius
Was this helpful?
quality pencils
quality pencils, sharpened, and received very quickly
Happy Customer
Was this helpful?
Preferred option for pencils
Easy ordering, quick shipping and exactly what I asked for on design. So far, the pencils have been of a much higher quality than the last company I ordered from.
Eric Wahlen
Was this helpful?
Easy, Accurate, Quick
The web site was clean and simple to glance at options and choose what fits my needs with immediate pricing laid out based on quantity and type of pencil to be ordered. Ordering was a breeze too with immediate confirmation receipts, proofs, and delivery tracker. Order arrived in two days! Pricing was also competitive. Excellent experience.
Scott Bonney
Was this helpful?
Perfect!
The pencils were exactly what I wanted, and the printing was better than I expected. I ordered a yellow pencil with black writing, and it was so clear and bold that it was perfect. My students are working hard to earn them as a reward.
Middle School Teacher
Was this helpful?
I love the Pencil Guy
I love the Pencil Guy! I searched prices and found his cost with shipping to be the best. My pencils were made the day I placed my order and came in perfectly!
Muffin Bernstein
Was this helpful?
Incredibly responsive
Incredibly responsive, great service, fast and accurate. 10/10
Taylor Sullivan
Was this helpful?
Pencils are good quality and arrived…
Pencils are good quality and arrived quickly.
Browne
Was this helpful?
I loved how easy it was to find what I…
I loved how easy it was to find what I needed on their website! Getting a proof to review before they started production was a great touch, and shipping was super fast. Fantastic experience!
Marie Jones
Was this helpful?
Great pencils and quick shipping
I’ve been engraving these pencils for the last 3 or 4 years. Engrave great -has cut down on my production time and shipping is really quick.
Carol Cvitkovich
Was this helpful?
So easy to get great service and a great product!
It was so easy to select the product that best fit my needs, get a proof to make sure it would look exactly as I wanted it to look, and get the final product delivered--looking as great as I had hoped!Brian is so friendly and professional. It's truly a joy to do biz with this company!
MC
Was this helpful?
Good quality
Good quality. I give them to my students instead of candy. LOL
John Zubris
Was this helpful?
The ad said nothing about them being…
The ad said nothing about them being made in China. Would have rather bought a USA made product.
Tim
Was this helpful?
Fast communication and an easy experience
Fast communication and an overall easy purchasing and experience. I've ordered before and will again!
Robin Ziari
Was this helpful?
I ordered custom pencils from…
I ordered custom pencils from Pencilguyshop and thy turned out great, the lettering was clear, they shipped fast, and customers service was friendly and responsive. The ordering process was simple and the pencil arrived exactly as previewed. Overall, a good experience, and I'd consider ordering from them again.
Heidi Summers
Was this helpful?
the pencils have been perfect
the pencils have been perfect - just as expectedthey seem to work as they shouldtimely and friendly response to concernsgood product in generalwe need more vendors like this - good experiencei've ordered 3 times and will continue with themmight get them cheaper ... but why take a chance
jorge zimmerman
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Pencilguyshop has a 4.9/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of February 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/pencilguyshop-com