Very easy process
Very easy process, fair price, prompt payment is all I need to say.
Brian Lewis
Was this helpful?
GoldFellow
5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 26, 2026Do you agree with GoldFellow's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 364 customers have already said.
goldfellow.comMember since Feb 2026
GoldFellow is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 26, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
GoldFellows was just right
GoldFellows was prompt, professional, and fair in pricing as far as I'm concerned. I will be doing business with them again in the future.
Becky Connolly
Was this helpful?
Customer service is excellent
Customer service is excellent. Very quick payout. Highly recommend!
Iris
Was this helpful?
GoldFellow is Amazing!
I have used GoldFellow numerous times. Every exchange they have shown to be professional, friendly, and trustworthy. Their purchase offers are excellent and I receive my offers the same day my items arrive at their location and am paid immediately. I highly recommend Goldfellow and will use them again and again.
Ann
Was this helpful?
Very clear process and directions
Very clear process and directions. No surprises.
customer
Was this helpful?
Quick, easy and great service!
This was such a quick and easy process, and I received outstanding communication from the company. I have already recommended you to others!
Colleen Vaughan
Was this helpful?
Very easy process.
Very easy process.
Judy
Was this helpful?
Great offers
Great offers, great service, prompt response to inquiries.
Leslie Miles
Was this helpful?
Great process and web interface
Great process and web interface. Enjoyed the ease of sending a gold item to Goldfellow for evaluation and sell offering. I liked what they offered and was excited that they used Zelle so I got my money fast. Would recommend to any friends or family to use for cashing in on unused gold.
Don Luttrell
Was this helpful?
Insanely fast turn around
Insanely fast turn around. Great service.
Shawn Montgomery
Was this helpful?
From the first phone call
From the first phone call, I knew this was a family organization that was warm in reception. Mailing my class ring with free shipping, the day it arrived I was paid. Excellent and hope to meet the staff in the future.
Tina
Was this helpful?
Seamless
Speedy, efficient service - the process was seamless.
Kathleen Kaiser
Was this helpful?
Amazing service
Amazing service
Sean Riley
Was this helpful?
Very pleased with service!
My order was received by you within 2 days of shipping. I had an offer the very next day (a Fri) and a check in hand by Mon. Very pleased! Thank you!
Mary
Was this helpful?
Using GoldFellow was super easy
Using GoldFellow was super easy & quick. After using multiple refiners/gold & silver buyers I've noticed there is a difference between the companies. GoldFellow called promptly & made selling my old jewelry super easy. Plus the customer service representative was charming over the phone. I will be glad to use this service again!
M. Kiggins
Was this helpful?
Have dealt w/ them in the past
This is probably the 3rd time I have dealt w/ them over the years. As always, the service is there. Ms. Hamilton is a pleasure to deal w/.
LYN MAAR
Was this helpful?
Very quick responses and payment
Very quick responses and payment. Great customer service.. I had a good past experience (years ago) so when I was in the market again, I used them, again. Happy to recommend!
Michele
Was this helpful?
Communication was the best
Communication was the best
Alfonso Ramirez
Was this helpful?
Easy and very quick
The process was easy and very quick. I also talked with Mary and she was so friendly and helpful.
JF
Was this helpful?
Goldfellow made it so easy to sale my…
Goldfellow made it so easy to sale my gold too. I really liked how they broke down the settlement for me. I would definitely recommend them to anyone.
Sheila Gragg
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, GoldFellow has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of February 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/goldfellow-com