Trust PlaneTrustPlane
Gittelson Jewelers logo

Gittelson Jewelers

5.07 reviews
Last reviewed: Jun 25, 2022

Do you agree with Gittelson Jewelers's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 8 customers have already said.

gittelsonjewelers.comMember since Mar 2026

Gittelson Jewelers is an online company. Based on 7 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed June 25, 2022.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
7 reviews

Stellar service, wonderful family

Gittelson Jewelers is an exceptional business. They provide stellar service no matter what you need or how much you spend. I had my great grandmother’s engagement ring; she’d pulled out the diamond to reset it in another piece. I went to several places for recommendations and cost estimates for getting a new diamond put in. I was astonished at how some other jewelers were dismissive because the ring wouldn’t fit a huge diamond; they were uninterested in the ring’s importance to my family. The Gittelsons’ respect for the piece and its history was wonderful. They offered me a range of options, and did a wonderful job on my beautiful ring. Service quality was equally high during other visits, even when I was making small purchases (or chose not to purchase at that time).

SRK
Was this helpful?

Gene and Michael have been a huge part…

Gene and Michael have been a huge part of the Hentges Family choices for about 40 years! They have made our families weddings, anniversaries and other event very special. Gene earned our trust in Gittelson’s for quality and value again and again. I highly recommend this business. Jeanette Hentges

Jeanette Hentges
Was this helpful?

Our entire family and many

Our entire family and many, many of our friends have used Gittelson Jewelers since they opened. Gene, Mike, and Molly only know outstanding customer service - they are always willing to go beyond the extra mile! Their merchadise is beyond compare. They stand 100% behind everything they sell. We have referred upwards of 30 or more friends to Gene and Mike and will continue to do so without hesitation! Gittelsons deserves 5+ Stars! Visit Gittelsons you won't be disappointed! Deb Murphy and Family

Debra Murphy
Was this helpful?

Customer service extraordinaire

Gene and Mike take great care of you. They are good listeners and provide solutions within my budget. I’d recommend anyone who is looking for jewelry to reach out to the Gittelsons!

adam olkon
Was this helpful?

Custom Wedding Ring

They custom made my spouse's wedding ring in 2018 and we absolutely love it. I brought my own stones and the final estimated value was much more than they charged me. I'm very happy with the design experience too, they were great to work with and their design tastes were superb.

Lor
Was this helpful?

I live in South Dakota

I live in South Dakota. Gene , Michael and Molly have the BEST customer service I have ever seen. 7 hours away I could find something closer but they are the best!! Whatever you need for service or jewelry they make it happen !! You won’t be disappointed!!Renae Collins

Renae Collins
Was this helpful?

They have always been extremely…

They have always been extremely friendly & helpful over the years. I work downtown & they are my go to jewelers.

Dawn Misencik
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, Gittelson Jewelers has a 5.0/5 rating based on 7 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/gittelsonjewelers-com