Trust PlaneTrustPlane
Ben Garelick logo

Ben Garelick

5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Jun 12, 2025

Do you agree with Ben Garelick's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 51 customers have already said.

bengarelick.comMember since Mar 2026

Ben Garelick is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed June 12, 2025.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
50 reviews

Personalized service, stunning work

I was thrilled to find out the ring I’d been dreaming of for years already existed at Ben Garelick (one of their original designs), but I was even more excited to find out it was surprisingly affordable and customizable. I reached out to ask about pricing and spoke with the owner himself, who really took the time to answer all my questions and provide upfront quotes. He never tried to upsell or pressure me and he offered to price-match the diamond, which saved me enough money to upgrade a full half carat and still come in under budget. Financing was a breeze and shipping was fast and secure. Buying from an individually owned and operated jewelry store instead of a big box retailer made all the difference in the world. I wasn’t treated like just a number on an invoice and I have peace of mind knowing they stand behind their work. This ring is a dream come true and I’ve enjoyed every step of the process with Ben Garelick. I can’t wait for my kids to fall in love so I can introduce them to Peter for their engagement rings!

CT Whitaker
Was this helpful?

We bought from Australia, definitely recommend!

We live in Australia and were looking for an engagement ring made by a particular designer (Kirk Kara). Ben Garelick was one of only two authorised retailers at the time, as the brand isnt available in Australia at all. Its not an easy decision to buy expensive jewelery from an online store, especially when its in another country. Theres a concern about the quality, fraud, and you cant see or touch the item so its a big leap of faith. However we had an amazing experience and would not hesitate to recommend this business to anyone, anywhere. We communicated entirely through email, and nothing was too much of a problem. From the sizing of the ring, and how it should feel when it goes on, and the amount of difficulty in getting it off, to even offering us a discount code for the checkout, we just had a wonderful, comforting, experience. We would absolutely buy from here again. A small warning to Australian residents in particular, the Government held our ring in customs until we could fill out a declaration form about the cost of the ring, and pay the import duties and GST on the entire purchase including the postage! LOL so ridiculous. So my advice would be if youre planning on going to the US, make the purchase when youre there, then have the item delivered to your hotel, and definitely dont declare it when you get back!! Otherwise budget for around 12% (to be safe) on top of the online price after conversion to AUD.

Michael
Was this helpful?

Perfect Honora happy earring back and the customer service also perfect.

The Honora happy earring backs are wonderful. They do just want they are suppose to to do make your earrings stand up on your ears. Also the packing was wonderful already gift wrapped in a lovely pouch. Thank You. Thinking I'll be ordering another pair . Oh my goodness they were outstanding to work with so helpful and fast.

Celeste
Was this helpful?

Absolutely wonder experience!!!

Absolutely wonder experience. Ben Garelick was very helpful every step of the way. Purchasing, sizing, and delivery couldn't have went any smoother. My wife loves this beautiful ring. Will certainly buy again. Thank you Ben Garelick!

Richard Marvich
Was this helpful?

There were consultants available online …

There were consultants available online for questions when ordering. I had 2 separate orders and both came early and quickly. I had a question and email responses were very prompt. It was a great experience.

kme
Was this helpful?

What customer service should be

I ordered a custom ring for the love of my life. From the start the service was exceptional. She love love loves her ring and I could not be more pleased!!

Marc Englebert
Was this helpful?

Very happy with Ben Garelick received …

Very happy with Ben Garelick received my purchase fast and it was just what I wanted.

Maria
Was this helpful?

Excellent service

Excellent service

Kristal
Was this helpful?

Ben Garelick went above and beyond …

Ben Garelick went above and beyond expediting my order. My fiance and I are super happy with engagement ring. Their customer service exceeded our expectations and we look forward to doing business with them in the near future. We highly recommend them!

Norma Denmark
Was this helpful?

Beautiful jewelry and amazing customer …

Beautiful jewelry and amazing customer service! Peter was a huge help in making sure my mom's 75th birthday gift was special! He provided suggestions and feedback on product very quickly over email. This allowed me to find the perfect diamond earrings for my mom.

Michelle Garvey
Was this helpful?

Excellent response on small order

Product shipped quickly, wrapped very well, and it was as advertised. Good attention to a very small order. Thank you!

Susan Shows
Was this helpful?

Quick and easy

Quick and easy! Got the ring I wanted and some extra things to help make the big moment special! Ring came in and was ready very fast!

Michael
Was this helpful?

Very professional

Very professional, thank you so much! My wife absolutely loves the ring!

Travis Robertson
Was this helpful?

Excellent service- utmost integrity and …

Excellent service- utmost integrity and helpfulness

Mike
Was this helpful?

Very very helpful through out the …

Very very helpful through out the entire buying process. I would recommend them to anyone based on their service alone.

Brett
Was this helpful?

The best in personal customer service

The best in personal customer service! From ring designs to buying gold....our favorite jewelry store 😊

Amy Jo Griffith
Was this helpful?

I recieved the ring yesterday and i …

I recieved the ring yesterday and i want to let you know that i absolutely love it, it is very beautiful:) Now i just need to get the diamond in the setting so i Can wear it :)

Dalby
Was this helpful?

We could not have been more pleased …

We could not have been more pleased with our experience with Peter Manka, Jr. and the Ben Garelick team! He patiently collaborated with us on a short timeline ensuring that the customized engagement/wedding ring was exactly as we wanted. I fell in love with my ring! The customer service was second to none!

Greg and Lynetta Moore
Was this helpful?

I would highly recommend Ben Garelick …

I would highly recommend Ben Garelick to anyone who has reservations about not purchasing an engagent ring in person. I worked with Peter and he did an amazing job of communicating with me and answering all of my questions. The ring arrived very quickly and it was breathtaking; my fiancee could not be happier with it.

Laura
Was this helpful?

A superior jeweler!

Ben Garelick jewelers is an incredible company. I have been buying my pieces here for many years, starting with my wedding bands and engagement ring to anniversary pieces and custom makes. Everyone there is very nice and pleasant to work with. They are knowledgeable and accommodating. I really appreciate their overall selection of jewelry. Their work and craftsmanship is excellent! As a whole, I feel, a superior jeweler. I am very pleased with my overall experience, and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a high quality piece with a knowledgeable and courteous staff to back it up. Definitely my jeweler now and in the future!!

Daniel Hildreth
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, Ben Garelick has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/bengarelick-com