Everything went smoothly and the cost…
Everything went smoothly and the cost of the INSURANCE is good
SIDNEY RAINS
Was this helpful?
American Collectors Insurance
5.050 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 28, 2026Do you agree with American Collectors Insurance's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 21,601 customers have already said.
americancollectors.comMember since Feb 2026
American Collectors Insurance is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 28, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Great experience
Easy process. Real person. Affordable rates.
TYLER ADAMS
Was this helpful?
Taylor was very knowledgeable and…
Taylor was very knowledgeable and provided an easy and efficient means of obtaining the right insurance for my vehicle. Very courteous and friendly.
SHAWN CHANDLER
Was this helpful?
Excellent customer service…
The people I had contact with while going over and purchasing the policy were knowledgeable and very helpful with questions I had.The entire process was excellent and the cost of the policy was very reasonable.
ALBERT CORDERO
Was this helpful?
Great experience with Jesse...
Jesse is very knowledgeable and easy to communicate with
STEPHEN SWANSON
Was this helpful?
Outstanding customer service
Cathleen was very helpful and knowledgeable and made sure all my needs were met.
DANIEL PIERCE
Was this helpful?
Angela was most helpful in explaining…
Angela was most helpful in explaining the insurance for my 1974Corvette
TERI LINARDICH
Was this helpful?
The agent was very knowledgeable
The agent was very knowledgeable, both of classic car uniqueness's and policies to cover them.
MARK
Was this helpful?
Easy to understand
Easy to understand, Representative Jason N. was super nice and very helpful. He gave great options, and helped us pick the right package for our needs. Explained everything and told us what documents to look for to e-sign. And he was a really personable, nice guy.
KATHY BARTLETT
Was this helpful?
Kathleen made the process smooth and…
Kathleen made the process smooth and simple.
Jonathan
Was this helpful?
My 1955 Glasstop gets insured
Easy and no pressure
CARL RUSSO
Was this helpful?
My Agent Nykesha was Promt to help me
My Agent Nykesha was Promt to help me. She was knowledgeable , Patient with my Questions. Followed up on emails. Best rate , same Coverage as the Hagerty quote I received. Hagerty Quote was higher. I will continue with American Collectors Insurance moving forward. Thank you.
THOMAS ADAMS
Was this helpful?
Super easy and really fast in getting a…
Super easy and really fast in getting a reasonable quote.
RODNEY ERIC SHELTON
Was this helpful?
Professional Demeanor
Professional Demeanor - Listened to my request - provided accurate information - patient - personable/friendly !
PATRICK BAUGUESS
Was this helpful?
Professionally guided me through the…
Professionally guided me through the process. Explained everything well. Process was easy with required documentation added online.
Daniel Ortegon
Was this helpful?
amy did a wonderful job
amy did a wonderful job
JOHN FERRO
Was this helpful?
the underwriter was very professional
the underwriter was very professional, friendly , clear and concise
neil alprin
Was this helpful?
Friendly courteous interaction was…
Friendly courteous interaction was great answered all my questions
CHARLES STULLER
Was this helpful?
Taylor was fantastic and pricing seemed…
Taylor was fantastic and pricing seemed very reasonable
MATT WILLIAMS
Was this helpful?
Helpful agent.
Helpful agent.
Keith Ames
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, American Collectors Insurance has a 5.0/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/americancollectors-com