SERVICE WAS GREAT …
SERVICE WAS GREAT BUT PORTION SIZE WAS DISAPPOINTING
richard westbrook
Was this helpful?
Whidbey Island Seafood Company
4.850 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 21, 2026Do you agree with Whidbey Island Seafood Company's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 1,061 customers have already said.
whidbeyseafoods.comMember since Feb 2026
Whidbey Island Seafood Company is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 21, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Took three tries to do an on-line order…
Took three tries to do an on-line order of two smoked black cod fillets but follow-up was excellent and fish delivered in person to our Lopez house. Thank you.
Lynn Thompson
Was this helpful?
BLACK COD
GREAT BLACK COD
Joseph Simas
Was this helpful?
As always - great fish!
As always, great quality fish from the N. Pacific and Alaska. Nicely, processed and packaged in sensible portions. Orders quickly filled and conveniently available locally or shipped to your door. We’ve been customers for three or four years now and are very pleased.
William Loomis
Was this helpful?
Product is still very good but prices…
Product is still very good but prices are getting higher and portions are getting smaller. Sorry you said to be honest Gordy
Gordy Anderson
Was this helpful?
Fabulous fresh food delivered to my…
Fabulous fresh food delivered to my door. I know it's history. Frozen right at the source. This is the way I get my seafood these days.
Susan Staker
Was this helpful?
The BEST seafood!!!
The BEST seafood!!!Wild caught, sustainable seafood from a family owned business that is beyond delicious!! HIGHLY recommend!!
Maureen Crist
Was this helpful?
I can always trust your fish to be the…
I can always trust your fish to be the freshest and most flavorful. You beat out my local market. Your packing is impeccable. Thank you for being there.
Ronni Fallows
Was this helpful?
Fresh Seafood, Fast Service
Seafood is so fresh and my order is ready same or next day.
Kristie K
Was this helpful?
Best Fish
I started ordering from Whidbey Island Seafood because they have the best and cleanest fish. I will now longer buy my fish from local grocery stores. I want the best food I can get. I highly recommend them.
Carolyn
Was this helpful?
Good seafoods
They have the best seafoods to deliver 😁. I’m lucky I found this company won’t stop patronizing them
Becca
Was this helpful?
GET AT THIS SEAFOOD COMPANY
I love this company they do the best with the seafood I’m so proud of whoever established this business
Alien User
Was this helpful?
Whidbey Seafoods is amazing
Whidbey Seafoods is amazing. We get our seafood exclusively from them and have been a customer for several years. The seafood is super fresh and incredibly delicious. Once we got spoiled by Whidbey, we couldn't go back to any other company. We also feel really good supporting local fisher-people, and not having to have seafood shipped across the country. We are loyal customers for life!
Karin Steere
Was this helpful?
What a bonus to have Whidbey Island…
What a bonus to have Whidbey Island Seafood in our midst. We picked up our first order, halibut, and enjoyed a delicious meal. Looking forward to more!
Sue Frause
Was this helpful?
Honest
Honest , reliable, and outstanding sea food
customer Ernesto fuentes
Was this helpful?
Tasty fish/great customer service
The fish is so tasty but the customer service is also amazing. My fish was delivered the next day to our home (we live on Whidbey Island) so we were able to plan a great fish dinner the next day. Thank you!
lisa jackson
Was this helpful?
High quality and diverse seafood…
High quality and diverse seafood options. We've never had any bad experiences with our orders!
Gregg Butsko
Was this helpful?
Great communication and customer…
Great communication and customer service. I shipped out of state as a gift. Easy-peasy. And they loved it! Would definitely purchase with the folks at Whidbey Seafoods again.
J Hopkins
Was this helpful?
Seafood just doesn't get any better or…
Seafood just doesn't get any better or fresher than this unless you catch it yourself.
Leslie Stevens
Was this helpful?
Easy and Excellent!
So easy to order and receive excellent seafood! Staff are extremely helpful and timely. Great taste and quality!!
Kelly Webb
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Whidbey Island Seafood Company has a 4.8/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/whidbeyseafoods-com