Do you agree with Top Shelf Cookies's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 474 customers have already said.
Top Shelf Cookies is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed January 1, 2026.
Top Shelf Cookies serves treats that are rich, and truly satisfying. The cookies arrived fresh and perfectly baked, just as you'd hope. it's a tasty choice for anyone craving sweet indulgence.
nice taste enjoyed a alot
Company doing great work. I recommended this product personally. Really satisfied
Excellent experience! They promptly fixed a shipping address error I made. The cookies arrived on time in Florida, and my sister adored them. Delicious cookies made with quality ingredients—highly recommend!
We thoroughly enjoyed the cookies. They were a gift for our friends and truly added a special touch to the season`s ceclebrations
When my order got lost in the mail, Heather went out of her way to make it right. A+ customer service. This is a small business I want to continue to support! Thank you, Heather!
Delicious cookies, delivered in a timely manner!
Top Shelf Cookies have been a surprise treat for my grandsons for the past several years.. and of course, back-to-school is a favorite time for a treat! The quality is second to none & they are devoured quickly!
Love the cookies and the service! Thank you Heather and team for always coming through with quick deliveries and amazing cookies.
Everything about Top Shelf is fantastic. The cookies, the service, the prices. Top Shelf is my go-to for gifts for family and friends.
Always a great experience buying cookies from Top Shelf. The online portal is easy to use. The cookies arrive fresh and when promised. And of course, they are delicious!
The process of ordering was easy and the deliverywas quick.
I can always count on Top Shelf Cookies to make it easy to order and for prompt shipping. Plus, the selection of flavors is always great!
Amazing service and the cookies are delicious! 10 out of 10 Highly recommend!
Fast delivery, tasty cookies
absolutely love the raspberry lime ricky cookies great job already recommended
cookies to dry
Great local cookie company. Worth the visit or placing an order for the delicatable flavors they have on regular and seasonal/special occasions. Their ice cream sandwiches are great treats in-store, using local creameries. A must if stopping by their brick-and-mortar.
Heather went out of her way to make good on a delivery issue. And the cookies are delicious
Excellent customer service.
According to TrustPlane, Top Shelf Cookies has a 4.9/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/topshelfcookies-com
