Sunset Island Dinner was a wonderful…
Sunset Island Dinner was a wonderful experience - great atmosphere, delicious food, and friendly staff
Zoe Matthews
Was this helpful?
Sunset Island Dinner
5.011 reviews
Last reviewed: Oct 24, 2025Do you agree with Sunset Island Dinner's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 11 customers have already said.
sunsetislanddinner.comMember since Feb 2026
Sunset Island Dinner is an online company. Based on 11 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed October 24, 2025.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
11 reviews
Forever memory with my husband
I cannot put into words just how stunning, intentional, magical, and just all around how beautiful our experience was with Sunset Island Dinner and Captain Gene. We wanted something different, unique, and memorable and our expectations were exceeded plus more!! If you’re looking for a forever memory with your special someone- BOOK NOW!!! The boat ride was peaceful and amazing views. Dinner was delicious and dessert was to die for. Loved the pictures we received and just all around the intimacy and privacy of the evening.
Suzette Hine
Was this helpful?
Perfect evening treat!
My fiancé and I had an amazing experience from the moment I booked to the moment it ended! We were greeted with kindness and respect! My fiancé didn’t have much of an idea of what was going on so captain gene and his lovely wife did a fantastic job at keeping details at bay! Our food was incredible and the sunset was priceless! I loved everything about it! Highly recommended for anybody who wants to experience a special moment or just some sweet one on one time with a special someone!
Tiffany
Was this helpful?
It was really a beautiful experience
It was really a beautiful experience. From the very beginning to the end.
Tychell
Was this helpful?
Gene and Cheri are phenomenal hosts and…
Gene and Cheri are phenomenal hosts and are great at what they do. They made me and my fiancé feel comfortable from the moment we met them and set up an evening we’ll never forget! Thank you Gene & Cheri!
Austin
Was this helpful?
Amazing experience
Amazing experience, one of a kind. Food was good, boat was clean, everything was clean and done respectfully.
Frank Gutierrez
Was this helpful?
This was possibly the most spectacular…
This was possibly the most spectacular evening I could have imagined for the love of my life on Valentines Day. Sunset made me look like a "romantic genious"! My input was to find the location and the rest was strategically orchestrated by Sunset...and orchestrate they did! Fromthe initial greeting to the goodbye. It was a surprise for my then girlfriend, but now my fiancee. She couldn't believe my thoughtfulness and the overwhelming uniqueness of the experience from a flower for her, a blanket for us to cuddle in on the boat ride back, to pictures taken at moments to capture the evening...what an experience! This was not a 5 star encounter, it was 10 stars!
S. James
Was this helpful?
While I can't review the experience and…
While I can't review the experience and food, I can review Captain Gene. Captain Gene watched the weather before our trip and made the decision to cancel due to wind which would have been detrimental to an enjoyable experience. He texted the day before to try to reschedule and kept me updated the day of. This kind of honesty and customer service is hard to find. I will definitely try again because of his commitment to providing the most romantic experience possibly.
JOHN
Was this helpful?
Great people and easy to work with
Great people and easy to work with. Dinner was good. Unique experience
Jacob
Was this helpful?
1st wedding anniversary
Would highly recommend the private island dinner cruise. We were celebrating our 1st wedding anniversary. It was so romantic and special. We will never forget it.
Richard & Janice
Was this helpful?
Perfect Romantic dinner
We had a beautiful sunset dinner on a private little beach at sunset. Absolutely gorgeous evening. Very different than anything else we've ever done. Food was excellent also.
Kortnie D.
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Sunset Island Dinner has a 5.0/5 rating based on 11 verified reviews as of March 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/sunsetislanddinner-com