This is the second time
This is the second time I've bought tires from here and I definitely will be buying here again!!
lawrence p
Was this helpful?
Priority Tire LLC
4.250 reviews
Last reviewed: Mar 1, 2026Do you agree with Priority Tire LLC's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 3,173 customers have already said.
www.prioritytire.comMember since Mar 2026
Priority Tire LLC is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed March 1, 2026.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Tires arrived quickly and were just how…
Tires arrived quickly and were just how they were described. I haven’t put them on my car yet but ordering from priority tire was easy and with the insurance included made it a easy choice
Jarrod Thibodeau
Was this helpful?
Great communication and easy fast…
Great communication and easy fast shipping
BORIS T
Was this helpful?
Received my tires in 3 days
Received my tires in 3 days. Got them mounted. Smooth ride and quiet on the road for an aggressive looking rugged terrain tire. So far so good.
Vincent Sanchez
Was this helpful?
We ordered and they came very quickly.
We ordered and they came very quickly.
Mary
Was this helpful?
I have bought several tires from Priority
I have bought several tires from Priority and delivery was great and tires were great too.
Lawerence Mayhelm
Was this helpful?
Fast shipping
Fast shipping, A+
Troy Buckner
Was this helpful?
They don't stand behind the product that they are selling
I ordered a set of four tires from priority tire. When I got them I took them and my wheels off my camper to have them replaced. One of the tires when they mounted it had a big bulge in the side of it like it had a broken radal. I had to go ahead and order another tire and then pay to have it changed over with the defected tire and now priority tire is telling me that since they were mounted on Wheels they cannot accept a return but they can help me fill out a claim with the manufacturer of the tire. A good company would accept your return and they would deal with the manufacturer not leaving the customer to do it. I'm sending back all the tires and I'm going to buy them somewhere else and I will never buy another tire for priority tire and I would warn anybody not to do business with this company
Rusty Perren
Was this helpful?
Sent me defective tires…
Updated:02/27/2026: Again, I stand by what I've reviewed. I wouldn't even trust this company. They pay to have their reviews CONTROLLED! What gets posted for the puclic to see and what gets scrubbed so you can't view negative comments on there website reviews! The bottom line is that they sent me defective tires where the tread came off under 20,000 miles! Their phone reps refused to assist and provide warranty information! Buyer beware of cheap tires of poor quality. Absolutely no help with tire claims. So in other words they sell you defective tires and then not back them with a warranty or recourse to get your money! I've contacted the US NSTA, and BBB in Fl. If I have to I will go to their corporate office in FL and then they will understand the seriousness of this situation! I have pictures of the defective tires but no way to post on the forum and no reference they say they generated to verify the reviews! Again, it screams scam! I'll never order tires from Priority Tire again and nor should anyone else!
Marcus
Was this helpful?
Buy at your own risk online from Priority Tire LLC.
Can't begin to express the frustration and anger with Priority Tire after I purchased a set of 4 tires back in Nov 2025.Priority Tire claims to use Fed-X but will opt for UPS and will not inform its customers they DO NOT provide insurance cover if purchased over Ebay. My tires got "allegedly" stolen on two separate days of delivered to a FireStone. The receiver claimed they never got them or saw them. I followed the steps of the customer support to start the process to get remedy. After several calls to Priority Tires Customer Service and UPS to follow the status of the claim, took me 3 months to get a refund for 2 of 4tires after UPS yelled fault for 2 two tires. But not until I called Priority Tires to ask for the refund.UPS closed the claim for the other two tires, rendering me at a loss because they didn't admit to a fault; therefore Priority Tire's position is "there's nothing we can do...sorry". It's now 4 months since Nov 24th 2025 since this incident has happened and neither UPS nor Priority Tire will admit fault to refund the rest of my money as they play a blame game. Do business with Priority Tires at your own risk. I’d advise asking for insurance coverage and request a sign on delivery. If not, they simply take your money after you spend your precious time waiting on support to address your issue. They will not honor any escalation to a decision maker like a manager and you will likely get disconnected from you call demanding customer support. I won’t ever do business with this company again after this experience, this is no excuse. Their shipping coverage is misleading and they will not advocate for their customers. PS: Priority Tires, as a repeat customer, you should refund me for the lost of the tires you chose to ship via UPS and not Fed-X as well not cover with shipping insurance. (2/26/26 update) The delivery was ambiguous, no address captured nor company name in the delivery photo to show as proof of evidence items were delivered to the location on the order form. Without shipping insurance on deliveries, tires and money paid for them can just vanish just like in my case. No one takes accountability for the second order lost. That's unacceptable!!
Steven Johnson
Was this helpful?
Great product fast shipping
Great product fast shipping
Robert Bentivegna
Was this helpful?
Fast shipping
Fast shipping
wade williams
Was this helpful?
It was awesome
It was awesome! I ordered them on a Sunday and they were delivered on Tuesday! Put them on the Jeep by Wednesday!
Karen Allons
Was this helpful?
Great for the price
Great for the going a week strong and they riding smooth
morgan fiedler
Was this helpful?
Very poor customer service or should I say no service
I ordered a set of four tires. They came on time when looking at the tire specification. It did not state that these are directional tires when I receive them I noticed on the tire. It says it is directional. These will be a good fit for my vehicle, I called priority. Let them know. I would like to order another set and that these tires did not fit the tire specifications on their website and they will not return them unless I pay $180 return shipping fee even though it is their advertising that does not say it is directional. Customer service is no service with this company.
Richard Dahlgren
Was this helpful?
Quick and easy delivery also super good…
Quick and easy delivery also super good tires for the price!!! Super affordable and reliable plus they have an option to have the tires installed at your location!!! 20/10 WILL RECOMMEND TO EVERYONE!!
Francisco Urieta
Was this helpful?
Website is super easy to navigate
Website is super easy to navigate. Good prices & fast shipping with multiple payments options.
john jacobi
Was this helpful?
Great deal
Great deal, great tires, delivered fast
Jesse O
Was this helpful?
Good experience
It was a good experience, I didn’t go through no complications
Tevez Pierre
Was this helpful?
Easy to order at a good price
Easy to order at a good price
Aaron Franklin
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Priority Tire LLC has a 4.2/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/prioritytire-com