Trust PlaneTrustPlane
GothamSteel logo

GothamSteel

1.812 reviews
Last reviewed: Jul 17, 2025

Do you agree with GothamSteel's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 12 customers have already said.

gothamsteel.comMember since Mar 2026

GothamSteel is an online company. Based on 12 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 1.8 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed July 17, 2025.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
12 reviews

I bought a set of the gold colored pans…

I bought a set of the gold colored pans with the bakeware about 3 years ago. It was advertised to be scratch proof with metals beating inside the large square pan, it was also advertised with a 10 year guarantee. My husband used a knife to cut a roast in said large square pan about 3 months after I got them, big scratches. The skillets I have had to use butter or coconut oil to cook eggs in and still if I scramble the eggs and then try cooking them, even with butter they have a tendency to stick. Then just last week I managed to boil some hummingbird nectar, and ruined my small pot. My cake pans have also become scratched. I love the color, and I love the idea, but am disappointed that they don't quite live up to the hype. Hopefully you can send me replacements that will be better. I DO love the knives. I got those I think last year, had them on the shelf for quite a while before I took them out of their package and actually started to use them.

Carol Gibson
Was this helpful?

Cheap garbage

Cheap garbage. Scratches super easily. I bought my set from Costco probably a year or so ago. Very disappointed. Says metal utensil safe, but it actually scratches very easy. Don't waste your money.

nunya biz
Was this helpful?

Not happy with this product at all

Not happy with this product at all. The first day I use the frying pan it's scratched and I was using a rubber utensil. Would not recommend

Sharon
Was this helpful?

Copper coated non-stick frying pans

They sell copper coated non-stick frying pans. They work brilliantly, but only for up to a few months. Then they begin to stick, and that gradually progresses until they are unusable, say, after 3 months. I've had several, and the story is the same. They even sent me replacements, but they too had a short life. Gotham are certainly aware of the issue.

MidAtlantian
Was this helpful?

“The pan doesn’t work properly

“The pan doesn’t work properly; every time I try to cook, the food sticks to the bottom, even when using oil or butter. It’s frustrating because it doesn’t deliver the promised results and makes cleaning a hassle. I wouldn’t recommend it.”

Milene Amaro
Was this helpful?

Stuck on you.

The handle hasn't broken or gotten hot. The screws haven't come out. But everything sticks to them, even milk!

Barry C
Was this helpful?

OMG, THE SCREWS CAME LOOSE AS I WAS COOKING

OMG. THE SCREWS CAME OFF AS I WAS COOKING MY FOOD, TOOK A PICTURE TO SHOW THE COMPANY. GOT A RESPONSE BUT NO ACTION, UNTIL I HAD TO REACHOUT TO THE CORPORATION, RECEIVED ANOTHER POT IN EXCHANGE FOR THE FRYING PAN. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY. RUN, CHANGE THE CHANNEL WHEN YOU SEE THE COMMERCIAL

anna
Was this helpful?

False advertising

Contrary to their tv ads,these pots and pans are(in my opinion)not worth the money! Made with aluminum,they dent extremely easy,scratch even easier,and the handles on covers conduct heath 100%,which means that one needs gloves,or a rag to lift the covers! The only positive point is that they(pots and pans)do not chip!

Stefan Lucu
Was this helpful?

Useless handles.

Bought a pot a while ago but the handles are useless, they are held by thin metal which broke and the magnets keep falling out. The lid handle is metal and gets really hot.Unlike other users the non stick seems ok.

Neil Turner
Was this helpful?

PLEASE DO NOT BUY, HONEST REVIEW!!!

Totally misrepresented by Gothamsteel. Loved the first few times used now after couple months everything sticks. Hard to get them clean also. Glad I haven't used metal utensils they would be ruined.

D Dugger
Was this helpful?

don’t believe the hype

Worked great the first few times, now I have to scrub even scrambled eggs off it. Don’t waste your money

Lm
Was this helpful?

Gotham at it's best

Loving my new pots and pans and they arrived sooner then what I expected.

Monsy B
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, GothamSteel has a 1.8/5 rating based on 12 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/gothamsteel-com