Company is Fraud
Raised home policy 42% after 1 year, no claims. Just a classic bait and switch. Moved to State Farm, better coverage and lower price.
Patrick Jaynes
Was this helpful?
American Modern Insurance Group
1.17 reviews
Last reviewed: Nov 15, 2025Do you agree with American Modern Insurance Group's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 7 customers have already said.
amig.comMember since Mar 2026
American Modern Insurance Group is an online company. Based on 7 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 1.1 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed November 15, 2025.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
7 reviews
Tried to scam me on insurance
Tried to scam me on insurance. I would not recommend these guys are all
Pamela Samano
Was this helpful?
I think this company may be a scam
I think this company may be a scam. I was unable to pay my premium through their website. Finally contacted an agent and paid my bill. Now, I get a random $25 unexplained charge on my card. I sent customer service a message asking what it was for. Crickets. I let them know that my difficulties with their website has caused me to look elsewhere. Now I cannot log into my account despite the fact that I've paid my premium and cannot even look at my coverage online to compare. I doubt they would pay if I had a claim.
Steve Loudermilk
Was this helpful?
Simply far too expensive
Simply far too expensive - and for far less (coach class) coverage. It's as if the entire insurance industry has become predatory. Major reforms are definitely needed
Terry
Was this helpful?
American modern is deceptive and don’t…
American modern is deceptive and don’t train tell agents that in order to get water damage coverage you have to add a rider. We had a water in our basement and told us sorry, we don’t cover water as part of the base coverage. I couldn’t believe it. I checked with our agent and he checked all the other companies he writes for and they were the only one that doesn’t include water damage by default.
Wes Clark
Was this helpful?
I had a renters insurance policy with…
I had a renters insurance policy with eRenter, underwritten by American Modern (Policy #104452118). My claim involved direct physical damage to my personal items due to mold. The policy clearly includes coverage for damage caused by fungi, wet or dry rot, or bacteria up to $10,000. Yet, my claim was denied — falsely blaming “poor ventilation” as the cause, despite the resulting mold being the covered peril.When I tried to get answers, a representative named Monique hung up on me and refused to return my calls. The lack of professionalism, the bad faith denial, and the misapplication of the policy terms are unacceptable.I’ve submitted formal complaints to the Florida Department of Financial Services, Attorney General’s Office, and other regulatory bodies. If you’re thinking about getting renter’s insurance through eRenter or American Modern — don’t. They do not stand behind their own policy language and treat their customers with blatant disregard.Do better.
Mina
Was this helpful?
Buyer Beware!
I was referred to this Company by USAA. Don't waste your time. I had a terrible interview with this Company's representative. He kept asking the same questions over and over three times. American Modern Insurance Group charges way too much for what it offers. I looked at their reviews, and they were one horror story after another. USAA should not offer this to its membership.
Anthony Calleja
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, American Modern Insurance Group has a 1.1/5 rating based on 7 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/amig-com