Scam
Update, Not only have I not received my order! After numerous e-mails and phone calls to the company, and no one ever answers, no response! Do not buy anything from these scammers!
John Hagman
Was this helpful?
Buttonsmith
4.750 reviews
Last reviewed: Mar 20, 2025Do you agree with Buttonsmith's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 333 customers have already said.
www.buttonsmith.comMember since Feb 2026
Buttonsmith is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed March 20, 2025.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Have ordered tons of these
Have ordered tons of these. Not because they wear out but because I love all the polka dot ones.
MKay
Was this helpful?
It has not been shipped / received
It has not been shipped / received
Louise Boyd
Was this helpful?
The collars were great
The collars were great! Well made and arrived quickly.
Guest
Was this helpful?
Quality Collar
Quick delivery, just what I ordered. I needed to change the number. The previous one was fine after 3 years.
Pat
Was this helpful?
Collar came quickly but difficult to read
Collar came quickly, and was a good price. The text however is printed in a way that you can't see it all as the collar is adjusted. The extra large print looks a little off and the phone numbers being under the buckle are impossible to read. A person would need to remove the collar to get the information. It feels well made however, and is probably worth the money spent.
Rebecca Holler
Was this helpful?
We love the product
We love the product. Thank you.
Jodi West
Was this helpful?
So fast!
Buttonsmith was able to help me out in a jam with a super fast turn around time and a great quality print!
Emma Redman
Was this helpful?
Product is good quality and just as…
Product is good quality and just as described
carole Leanza
Was this helpful?
Beautiful Collars
Collars were beautiful and well made!
Lisa Ravenscraft
Was this helpful?
One of our dogs already had to call her…
One of our dogs already had to call her when we got her. She needed to be rehome. So I got her a new one and her other dog one before he passed away. Then our current dog we have besides the one he's broke. So instead of going back to the pet store I decided to get them from you guys again. I also like the price and how easy it was to do and how quick it got to us.
Ruth Nachtwey
Was this helpful?
Order received correct and promptly
Order received correct and promptly. This order replaces the exact 2 collars my dogs have worn for 5 years. The original collars were in fine working order and still very legible. Both dogs love the water and spend a lot of time outdoors in rough terrain. Thought they deserved a fresh look. If I had not been able to get these exact collars I would not have replaced them.
Joyce Ridenour
Was this helpful?
Fast shipping and a good quality made…
Fast shipping and a good quality made in the USA product. Love all of the different prints! We have 5 dogs & they all have Buttonsmith collars.
Chaka
Was this helpful?
Really sturdy dog collars that slide…
Really sturdy dog collars that slide around freely on my dogs' necks with all of their very long hair. It doesn't make tangles.
AmyIdaho
Was this helpful?
Leash and collar
This is a great company to work with and I’m very happy with the dog collar and leash I received for my little dog.
Jodi Correll
Was this helpful?
Super easy to find and a large…
Super easy to find and a large selection to choose from.
Natalie Olsen
Was this helpful?
Great quality
Great quality! Great customer service! Great product!
Fattie Tabor
Was this helpful?
Earned my gratitude and fierce loyalty
Absolutely above and beyond every step of the way. Y’all have earned my gratitude and my fierce loyalty.
KimY
Was this helpful?
Everything was easy
Everything was easy, from ordering to delivery. It was exactly as advertised. I like the fact that it’s made in the USA! If I may make a suggestion . . . I would like a button of the US Army Air Corps roundel. If you let me know if that’s possible, I’ll be the first one to buy it!
Brent Black
Was this helpful?
High quality product and reasonable…
High quality product and reasonable shipping time.
John Anctil
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Buttonsmith has a 4.7/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of February 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/www-buttonsmith-com